I've been wondering about Fred Flintstone.
You remember his car, of course. A wonderful piece of prehistoric engineering. Four stone wheels, a wooden frame, a roof, and a rather inconvenient hole in the floor.
The engine was Fred's feet.
Now, imagine that one day Barney Rubble comes rushing over with an extraordinary invention.
"Fred! I've invented something! It's called an engine. You put it in your car, press a pedal, and it moves without you having to run!"
What would Fred have said?
Would he have thrown his arms up in horror?
"An engine? Absolutely not! That's cheating! Real driving means using your feet!"
Or would he have climbed straight into Barney's workshop and asked when he could have one fitted?
I suspect I know the answer.
And while he was there, he might have asked whether Barney could do something about those stone wheels. A nice set of rubber tyres would surely have made the journey to the quarry rather more comfortable.
Of course, Fred was perfectly entitled to keep his stone wheels and foot-powered car. If he enjoyed wearing out his shoes every morning, that was entirely his business.
But would he have been justified in criticising everyone who chose something different?
That's where things become interesting.
The Music Never Stood Still
Consider the history of music.
For centuries, musicians have been finding new ways to create sounds, control them, combine them and share them.
The great pipe organs filled cathedrals with extraordinary music, using air passing through ranks of pipes. The harpsichord produced its distinctive sound by plucking strings. Then came the piano, allowing musicians to control the force and expression of individual notes in ways the harpsichord could not.
These instruments didn't all appear in a neat sequence, with one replacing another. They developed, overlapped and continued to find their own places in music.
And that is precisely the point.
New possibilities didn't make the old ones worthless.
Then came electronic organs, electric pianos, synthesisers and digital keyboards. A musician could suddenly explore an orchestra's worth of sounds without having an orchestra sitting in the room.
Was that cheating?
What about the electric guitar? Amplification, distortion, effects pedals — all technologies that transformed the instrument into something its earliest makers could scarcely have imagined.
Then recording itself changed everything.
In the early days of commercial recording, musicians often gathered together and performed into a recording system that captured their combined performance.
Multitrack recording changed that.
A musician could record one part, then another, then another. Voices could be layered. Instruments could be added, replaced, adjusted or removed. An entire musical arrangement could be built piece by piece.
Suddenly, the recording studio wasn't merely a place to capture a performance.
It had become an instrument in its own right.
And the innovations kept coming.
Drum machines. Sampling. Digital recording. Computer-based mixing. Pitch correction. Auto-Tune. Software instruments. Technologies that allowed sounds to be stretched, reshaped, combined and transformed.
Some musicians embraced these developments enthusiastically. Others preferred more traditional approaches.
And both continued to make music.
And Then There Was the Way We Listened
Of course, it wasn't only the making of music that changed. The way we listened to it underwent a revolution of its own.
I remember 78 rpm records. Heavy, fragile things that generally gave us only a few minutes of music on each side. You handled them carefully, and if you dropped one, there was a very good chance you'd be sweeping up the pieces.
Then came the long-playing record, the LP, turning at 33⅓ revolutions per minute. Suddenly, we could enjoy an entire collection of songs without having to change the record every few minutes.
The 45 rpm single became another familiar part of our lives, along with the EP, which squeezed several tracks onto a smaller disc.
Then magnetic tape opened up a whole new world.
Reel-to-reel tape recorders allowed us to record music ourselves. Eight-track cartridges found their way into cars, bringing music to the road without the inconvenience of changing records.
Compact cassettes became enormously popular. We could record our favourite songs, make compilations, carry music around and play it almost anywhere.
Then came the compact disc.
No needles. No worn grooves. No rewinding tapes. Just put the disc in and press Play.
Later, DVDs and other digital discs offered additional ways to enjoy music, sometimes accompanied by video and surround sound.
And then the physical medium began to disappear altogether.
Music became digital files. WAV, FLAC, MP3 and other formats allowed us to store enormous collections on computers, phones and portable players.
Today, we can stream almost any piece of music we want, virtually anywhere in the world, often within seconds of deciding we'd like to hear it.
Think about that for a moment.
We've gone from carefully lowering a needle onto a fragile shellac record to carrying access to millions of recordings in our pockets.
And through all those changes, what were we actually trying to do?
Listen to music.
Enjoy it. Be entertained by it. Be moved by it.
The purpose never changed. Only the methods did.
Of course, every new format had its advantages and disadvantages. Some people still prefer the sound and ritual of vinyl records. Others appreciate the convenience of streaming. And there are perfectly reasonable arguments about sound quality, ownership and the economics of music distribution.
But imagine someone insisting that listening to a CD wasn't really listening to music because it didn't involve a needle travelling through a groove.
Or that streaming a song somehow made the melody less beautiful because there was no record to hold in your hands.
We'd find that a rather peculiar argument.
Yet throughout the history of recorded music, people have repeatedly had to adjust their thinking as new technologies emerged.
Some welcomed the changes. Others resisted them. Some eventually changed their minds, while others happily continued enjoying their old equipment.
And why shouldn't they?
The important thing was that the music continued to reach people.
Perhaps that's the most remarkable part of the story.
Technology didn't simply make music more convenient. It allowed music to travel further, reach more people and become part of lives it might otherwise never have touched.
A song recorded on one side of the world can now be heard on the other side almost instantly.
And somewhere, someone might hear it at exactly the moment they need it.
Surely that's progress worth celebrating.
But Is It Real Music?
It's a curious question, isn't it?
If a musician plays a piano, we accept the result as music.
If the same musician plays an electronic keyboard, is it somehow less musical?
If a drummer plays a rhythm on an acoustic drum kit, we accept it. If someone constructs that rhythm using sampled drums, does the rhythm suddenly lose its value?
And if a singer's voice is recorded, layered, processed or corrected, at what point does the technology supposedly invalidate the music?
There are legitimate questions about authenticity, originality, credit and honesty. Those deserve thoughtful answers.
But the mere presence of technology tells us remarkably little about the quality or value of what has been created.
A sophisticated recording studio cannot guarantee a beautiful song.
Neither can an expensive piano.
The tools may offer possibilities, but someone still has to decide what is worth creating.
The Difference Between Making Something and Making Something Worthwhile
I've always believed that the most important part of creating music is not simply producing a collection of notes.
It's what those notes do to us.
A melody can make us smile. A voice can remind us of someone we love. A particular harmony can bring back a memory we thought we'd forgotten.
Sometimes music can move us to tears without our quite understanding why.
That emotional experience is what interests me.
The technology used to create it is important, certainly. But it's a means to an end.
I don't judge a beautiful photograph by how difficult the camera was to operate. I don't enjoy a painting more because the artist ground their own pigments. And I don't find a piece of music more moving simply because it took longer to produce.
I care about the result, the thought behind it, and what it communicates.
That doesn't mean the process is unimportant. For many people, the pleasure of playing an instrument, developing a skill or working with traditional methods is an essential part of their creative lives.
And that's wonderful.
But surely we can respect that pleasure without insisting that everyone else must work the same way.
Progress Is Not an Obligation
Here's something that often gets overlooked.
Progress doesn't require us to throw away everything that came before.
People still play harpsichords. Magnificent pipe organs are still being maintained and played. Acoustic guitars haven't disappeared because electric guitars exist. And some of the world's finest musicians continue to prefer instruments and recording techniques that have been around for generations.
They're not wrong.
They're choosing the methods that best suit what they want to achieve.
A photographer may prefer film. A painter may prefer oils. A musician may prefer an acoustic piano.
Those choices are every bit as legitimate as choosing newer technology.
But the freedom to choose must work both ways.
If you prefer traditional methods, enjoy them. Preserve them. Celebrate them. Teach them to the next generation.
Just don't assume that someone who chooses a different method has somehow diminished your own.
Back to Fred
So let's return to Bedrock.
Barney has fitted an engine to his car. He's replaced the stone wheels with rubber tyres. He can now drive to work without running all the way.
Fred, meanwhile, has decided to keep his original car.
And that's perfectly fine.
Perhaps he enjoys the exercise. Perhaps he likes the simplicity. Perhaps he simply loves his old car.
But imagine Fred standing at the roadside, shaking his fist at Barney as he drives past.
"That's not real driving!"
We'd probably laugh.
Because we can see something Fred cannot.
The purpose of the car was never to wear out Fred's feet.
It was to take him somewhere.
And perhaps that is something worth remembering whenever a new technology changes the way we do things.
We don't have to embrace every invention. Not every new development is necessarily an improvement, and progress brings responsibilities as well as opportunities.
But neither should we confuse familiarity with superiority, or difficulty with virtue.
Sometimes the old way is the best way.
Sometimes the new way opens a door we never knew existed.
And sometimes the most interesting things happen when we combine the two.
One Final Irony
There's one last thought that rather amuses me.
Every day, we see people online complaining about technological progress in music. Some are quite passionate about it. Others are positively indignant, insisting that things should be done the way they've always been done.
And they're perfectly entitled to their opinions.
But perhaps, before launching into another furious denunciation of modern technology, they might stop for a moment and consider something.
How exactly are they sharing those opinions?
On a computer.
Or perhaps a smartphone.
Using the internet.
Quite possibly while listening to digitally recorded music through wireless headphones.
All extraordinary products of the technological progress they already enjoy.
There's nothing wrong with questioning new technology. We should question it. We should understand it, examine its consequences and decide how best to use it.
But condemning progress simply because it changes familiar ways of doing things is another matter entirely.
And if you're going to become a keyboard warrior in defence of the good old days, perhaps it's worth remembering that the keyboard itself is a rather remarkable piece of modern technology.
I wonder what Fred Flintstone would make of that.
Perhaps he'd put down his stone tablet, smile, and ask Barney where he could get one.
Peter Pickering
Sessions on the Green®
